The BJP has approached the Shimla superintendent of police seeking an inquiry and possible registration of an FIR over remarks made by Himachal Pradesh Revenue Minister Jagat Singh Negi on Rafale aircraft and Operation Sindoor. The complaint relates to comments made in the state legislative assembly on 18 November, according to BJP media convener Karna Nanda.
Nanda said the minister’s remarks about Rafale aircraft prices and the outcome of Operation Sindoor raised concerns because they related to the armed forces and a military operation. The BJP has asked the police to determine whether any cognisable offence was committed outside the protection available to statements made inside the House.
“Sensitive issues concerning the armed forces required utmost responsibility from public representatives,” BJP media convener Karna Nanda said.
The complaint also requests the preservation of certified copies and video recordings of the assembly proceedings. It asks the police to examine whether Negi repeated or expanded on the remarks through media interviews, public platforms or social media, where separate legal consequences could arise if an offence is established.
Complaint refers to provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita
The BJP has referred to provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, including:
- Section 197(1)(d), described in the complaint as relating to false or misleading information affecting sovereignty or security;
- Section 353, concerning statements conducing to public mischief; and
- Section 152, concerning acts endangering the sovereignty, unity and integrity of India.
The complaint also refers to other applicable provisions and asks the police to assess the facts before deciding whether a cognisable offence has been made out. The request is not a finding that any offence was committed, and the starting of an inquiry or registration of an FIR would not amount to a judicial determination of guilt.
Assembly privilege remains part of the complaint
Nanda acknowledged the constitutional protection for speeches made in the state legislature under Article 194(2). The BJP’s position, as described in the complaint, is that this protection must be considered separately from any statement or conduct that may have taken place outside the Assembly. The party has therefore asked police to investigate any independently punishable act beyond the House.
The complaint follows a political dispute in Himachal Pradesh over references to the cost of Rafale aircraft and the results of Operation Sindoor. The material provided does not establish that Shimla police have registered an FIR, begun an investigation or taken action against the minister. Negi’s response to the complaint has also not been reported.